And, “here we are!” For their May wedding, the pair wanted something Brenna called “Jumanji Attic Chic.” The vision? “Let’s pretend you have a wealthy, worldly, eccentric great-aunt ...

"She awkwardly told me she and her fiancé had decided to only have 'people who really fit the aesthetic' in the wedding," he recalled. "When I pushed for an explanation, she eventually admitted ...